They Didn’t Raise Prices — They Raised Profits: How Smokey John’s BBQ Fired the Middleman and Grew 15%

The Silent Killer in Your Kitchen: Why Delivery Apps Are Eating Your Profits

Every restaurant owner knows the drill. The buzz of new orders, the promise of expanded reach, the convenience of third-party delivery apps like Uber Eats and DoorDash. It sounds like a dream, right? More customers, less hassle. But beneath the surface of convenience lies a silent killer, slowly but surely eroding your hard-earned profits: exorbitant commission fees, a lack of control, and a gaping void in customer data.

For years, restaurants have grappled with this dilemma. The allure of increased order volume often blinds them to the true cost of these partnerships. Imagine pouring your heart and soul into crafting the perfect meal, only to see 30% or more of your revenue vanish into the pockets of a delivery giant. 

It’s a bitter pill to swallow, and for many, it’s unsustainable. Beyond the financial drain, there’s the loss of direct customer relationships, inconsistent delivery experiences, and the inability to truly understand and market to your most loyal patrons. This was the harsh reality facing Smokey John’s BBQ, a beloved family-run institution in Dallas, Texas.

The Dallas Dilemma: Smokey John’s Confronts the Commission Conundrum

Smokey John’s BBQ, a second-generation family business renowned for its authentic Texas barbecue and strong local following, found themselves caught in this very trap. Their reputation for comfort food and community spirit was undeniable, but their reliance on third-party delivery apps was systematically undermining their success. 

The numbers were stark: commissions on platforms like Uber Eats and DoorDash were consistently exceeding 30% of every order. This wasn't just a dent in their margins; it was a gaping hole.

But the problems extended far beyond just money. The customer experience, a cornerstone of Smokey John’s hospitality, was suffering. Delivery times were inconsistent, service quality was unpredictable due to reliance on gig workers, and customer feedback often pointed to app-related issues rather than the quality of their food. 

Perhaps most critically, they had no access to their own customer data. 

This meant no remarketing opportunities, no loyalty programs, and no way to truly understand who their customers were or how to build lasting relationships. They were essentially renting their customers from the apps, with no ownership or control.

Firing the Middleman: How Smokey John’s Reclaimed Control

Recognizing that the status quo was unsustainable, Smokey John’s made a bold decision: they would take back control. Their solution wasn't a quick fix but a strategic pivot towards a zone-based, self-delivery system. This comprehensive approach allowed them to regain full operational command and reassert their brand presence.

Here’s how they did it:

• Internal Delivery Team: They established their own in-house delivery staff, covering specific zones. This eliminated reliance on unpredictable gig workers, ensuring consistent service and timely deliveries.
  
  
• Commission-Free Online Ordering: They transitioned to their own online ordering system, completely eliminating the crippling commission fees. This was a direct investment in their own profitability.
  
  
• Rebuilding Customer Engagement: With direct customer access, they leveraged SMS, email, and loyalty offers to rebuild and strengthen customer relationships. This allowed for targeted marketing and genuine community building.
  
  
• Leveraging Brand and Hospitality: They leaned into their strong brand story and renowned hospitality, driving direct orders through their own channels rather than relying on app-driven traffic.

The Tech That Made It Happen: Features for Freedom

The transition wasn't just about a change in strategy; it was enabled by smart technology choices. Smokey John’s implemented a system with key features designed to support their new, independent operation:

• Zone-Based Delivery Radius Configuration: This allowed them to define precise delivery areas, optimizing routes and ensuring efficient service within their chosen zones.
  
  
• Branded Ordering Site with Local SEO Optimization: Their own online ordering platform was fully branded, providing a seamless customer experience that reinforced their identity. Local SEO ensured they were discoverable by customers searching for BBQ in their area.
  
  
• In-House Delivery Staff Management: Tools for managing their own delivery team, including dispatch and tracking, were crucial for operational efficiency.
  
  
• Order Tracking with Customer Notifications: Customers received real-time updates on their orders, enhancing transparency and satisfaction.
  
  
• Direct Marketing Tools (Email/SMS Loyalty Offers): This was a game-changer, allowing them to directly communicate with their customer base, run promotions, and build loyalty.
  
  
• POS-Integrated System for Inventory and Order Routing: Seamless integration with their Point of Sale system streamlined operations, from order placement to kitchen fulfillment and delivery.

The Payoff: Tangible Results and Unprecedented ROI

Smokey John’s bold move paid off handsomely. The results were not just encouraging; they were transformative, demonstrating a clear return on their investment in owning their delivery and ordering experience.

• Delivery Revenue Soared: Despite not raising prices, delivery revenue increased by a remarkable 15%. This growth was purely organic, driven by their newfound control and direct customer engagement.
  
  
• Commission Fees: A Thing of the Past: The most immediate and impactful change was the complete elimination of third-party commission fees. This directly translated into significantly improved profit margins on every delivery order.
  
  
• Customer Satisfaction Skyrocketed: With their own dedicated delivery team, consistency and quality improved dramatically, leading to overwhelmingly positive customer feedback and a stronger brand reputation.
  
  
• Loyalty and Repeat Orders Strengthened: Direct marketing tools and a personalized customer experience fostered deeper brand loyalty, resulting in a significant increase in repeat orders.
  
  
• Average Order Value Increased: Through strategic upselling tools integrated into their own platform, Smokey John’s successfully boosted their average order value, further enhancing profitability.
  
  

This wasn't a massive chain with an unlimited tech budget. Smokey John’s is a testament to the power of strategic decision-making and the courage to challenge the status quo. They simply chose control over commissions, and it paid off in spades. By owning their delivery and ordering experience, they grew profits without needing more foot traffic or resorting to price hikes.

Why It Matters: Lessons from the BBQ Pit

Smokey John’s story is more than just a case study in successful restaurant operations; it’s a masterclass in strategic business thinking. Their journey offers invaluable lessons for any entrepreneur or restaurant/marketplace operator looking to take control of their delivery and ordering experience. Here are some key takeaways:

• The True Cost of Convenience: While third-party apps offer convenience, their hidden costs—high commissions, lack of data, and loss of customer control—can be detrimental to long-term profitability and brand building. Always calculate the true ROI.
  
  
• Ownership is Empowerment: Owning your technology and your customer relationships empowers you to dictate your terms, control your brand narrative, and build a sustainable business model.
  
  
• Data is Gold: Access to customer data is not just a luxury; it’s a necessity for effective marketing, loyalty programs, and understanding consumer behavior. Without it, you’re flying blind.
  
  
• Customer Experience is Paramount: In a competitive market, a consistent and high-quality customer experience can be your biggest differentiator. In-house control allows you to deliver on this promise every time.
  
  
• Innovation Doesn't Require a Massive Budget: Smokey John’s proved that even a family-run business can implement sophisticated solutions with strategic planning and the right technology partners.

Mental Models for Modern Restaurateurs

Consider these frameworks as you navigate the complex landscape of online ordering and delivery:

The Ownership Economy’ Mindset:
This concept emphasizes the value of owning the platforms and infrastructure that drive your business, rather than relying on third-party intermediaries. Smokey John’s embraced this by building their own delivery and ordering tech.

The ‘Flywheel Effect:

By owning their customer data and direct marketing channels, Smokey John’s created a positive feedback loop. Improved customer satisfaction led to more repeat orders, which in turn generated more data, allowing for even more effective marketing and loyalty programs. This creates a self-reinforcing cycle of growth.

First-Party Data Advantage:

In an increasingly data-driven world, having direct access to your customer data (first-party data) is a significant competitive advantage. It allows for personalized marketing, better understanding of customer preferences, and ultimately, more effective business decisions.

Ready to Reclaim Your Profits and Power Your Growth?

Smokey John’s BBQ’s journey is a powerful testament to the fact that you don’t have to sacrifice your profits for convenience. By taking control of your online ordering and delivery experience, you can unlock significant revenue growth, build stronger customer relationships, and future-proof your business.

Are you tired of commission fees eating into your margins? Do you want to own your customer data and build a loyal customer base? It’s time to explore how you can build your own growth engine.

Try our platform today and experience the difference of true ownership!

Book a demo with our experts to see how we can tailor a solution for your business.

Download our free ebook: "Why the Smartest Businesses Are Ditching Delivery Apps and Building Their Own Growth Engines." (Coming Soon!)

Explore more success stories of businesses like yours who have taken control and thrived.

Visual Summary: Before vs. After Taking Control

Try our platform